Women and the World International Film Festival 2026: Lilly and the Price of Justice

Four generations of Charles Ledbetter's family had belonged to the same church. His father and grandfather had served as pastors, and Charles, a military veteran, had been invited to address the congregation himself. Yet in Rachel Feldman's Lilly (2024), the invitation is abruptly withdrawn. His wife, Lilly Ledbetter, has sued Goodyear Tire & Rubber, the tire manufacturer where she worked for nineteen years, after discovering she earned considerably less than her male colleagues. Goodyear is one of the biggest employers in their Alabama town, and a congressman championing local industry is due to visit the church. The pastor would rather avoid the controversy. Four generations of belonging, undone by a single legal challenge. Starring Patricia Clarkson, Lilly opened the third Women and the World International Film Festival on 5 November at London's Ham Yard Hotel.
Founded by Ukrainian media professionals Mariia Vynogradova and Ksenia Bugrimova after the war brought them to the UK, the festival began as a platform for Ukrainian filmmakers before widening its focus to women's stories worldwide. Running until 12 November, it sees cinema as a way of encouraging empathy and peacebuilding. Lilly is a fitting choice, particularly given its own struggle to reach the screen. Unable to secure traditional Hollywood financing, Feldman turned to more than 200 independent investors and donors, around 85% of them women in their 50s and 60s. The backers pooled their resources during the pandemic, while women also led much of the film's post-production and music, including an end-credits song by Liz Rose. That a film about a woman challenging an entrenched system should reach audiences through the efforts of other women seems especially appropriate for this festival.
The Lilly Ledbetter we first meet is hardly the woman one might expect to take on a multinational corporation. Having grown up in poverty, she is delighted to secure one of the most sought-after jobs in her Alabama town. At Goodyear, hard work promises a better life for her family, provided she can tolerate the resentment of the men she now works alongside. As one of the factory's first female supervisors, Lilly faces hostility from male colleagues, while even her husband Charles (John Benjamin Hickey) initially struggles with the idea of his wife becoming another breadwinner. Still, she perseveres, hoping her dedication will eventually be recognised. For nineteen years, she has no idea that men doing comparable work are earning more.
When she eventually challenges the disparity, the hostility follows her beyond the factory gates. Goodyear supports much of the town, including people Lilly has known all her life. Her family's property is vandalised, and the church that once welcomed Charles's family turns them away. Feldman handles that confrontation particularly well. The pastor's matter-of-fact refusal is humiliating enough without dramatic embellishment, and Clarkson allows the hurt of the encounter to settle. Apparently, community loyalty has its limits when a powerful employer is involved. Watching the Ledbetters become outsiders in their own town, I found myself wondering how many employees would abandon a legitimate discrimination claim rather than risk the same treatment.
The courtroom offers little more comfort. Lilly wins her sex-based pay discrimination claim under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act 1964 before a jury, only for the verdict to be overturned. In Ledbetter v Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co (2007), the Supreme Court rules against her by a 5–4 majority. Its decision turns on the 180-day period for filing a discrimination charge: the deadline ran from the discriminatory pay decisions, and later paycheques did not restart it.
Having studied the case as a law student, I knew the outcome, but watching it unfold was still maddening. A jury had accepted Lilly's claim, yet a filing deadline would ultimately determine whether she could obtain a remedy. Limitation periods have their purpose, but pay discrimination can remain hidden for years. How was Lilly supposed to challenge a disparity she had no means of discovering? The film moves rather quickly from her initial conversations with her lawyers into the courtroom, which feels like a missed opportunity. Given how much her case eventually turns on a technical deadline, I would have liked to see more of Lilly trying to understand the legal system she had trusted to protect her.
The real surprise for me came after the Supreme Court's ruling. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's dissent declared that "the ball is in Congress' court", and Lilly took the invitation literally, making her way from office to office on Capitol Hill. Politicians acknowledge the unfairness of her situation while calculating what supporting her might cost them in business backing or campaign contributions. Having studied the formal stages of lawmaking, I found the political bargaining behind those procedures particularly revealing. Lilly eventually learns to turn those calculations to her advantage, but it is hardly an encouraging picture of how legal reform happens.
Watching Clarkson's Lilly grow increasingly comfortable confronting these politicians is one of the film's greatest pleasures. The uncertainty of her early years at Goodyear has given way to a sharp, stubborn confidence. In one memorable exchange, a congressman attempts to belittle her rural upbringing while questioning why she is lobbying for equal pay when her husband is seriously ill. Lilly recalls swimming in ponds as a child and dryly informs him that she knows how to burn off a leech. Clarkson delivers the remark beautifully. Having spent years being dismissed by men at Goodyear, she now seems perfectly comfortable putting a congressman in his place. There is a certain satisfaction in watching her become adept at navigating the very political interests that had initially stood in her way.
Her persistence culminates in the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act, signed in January 2009 as the first law of Barack Obama's presidency. The legislation established that each discriminatory paycheque can start a new filing period, addressing the interpretation that had defeated her claim. Lilly, however, never recovered her own lost wages. After years spent fighting for justice, the legal victory bearing her name offered her no financial compensation.
In contrast to the subtlety of Clarkson' s performance, Feldman’s soundtrack frequently pushes harder than the scenes demand. The closing refrain of Mickey Guyton's 'Remember Her Name' is almost exaggerated in its emphasis; between a film titled Lilly, legislation bearing her name and a narrative devoted entirely to her experiences, I hardly needed the soundtrack to remind me whose name I should remember. At times, Lilly also seems unable to decide whether it wants to be a biopic or a documentary. Archival footage of Ginsburg and other historical material repeatedly interrupts the dramatised scenes, pulling viewers away from Clarkson just as we became absorbed in her portrayal. The footage provides valuable context, but the church conf
rontation had already demonstrated how effective the film could be when it allowed its actors to carry the emotion.
I came into the screening knowing Ledbetter v Goodyear as a judgment and left with a much greater appreciation of the woman who had lived through it. Clarkson makes Lilly a moving and worthwhile watch, even when Feldman's musical choices and documentary interludes threaten to overwhelm her performance. Nearly two decades after the Fair Pay Act, significant gender pay disparities persist, and the difficulties employees face in challenging powerful employers remain painfully relevant. Lilly's victory deserves to be celebrated, but there is something profoundly unsettling about how much was demanded of the woman who achieved it. She changed American employment law, yet never recovered the wages she had lost. The legal system that made such a struggle necessary deserves every bit as much scrutiny as the woman who forced it to change.
By Vasavi Singh, edited by Isabella Greenaway
























Comments